Tom Jaconelli FRCEM book honest review

Reviewer disclosure: this is a synthesis of verified-purchase reviews on Amazon and posts from r/doctorsUK and r/emergencymedicine, plus the publisher’s own description. It is not a personal completion review — treat it as a peer-to-peer summary of how candidates actually report finding the book.

TL;DR. SBAs for the FRCEM by Tom Jaconelli is a 200-question SBA practice book from Cambridge University Press (Sept 2022, 180 pages, £31 RRP). It carries a 4.4/5 Amazon UK rating across 38 reviews and was the first book mapped to the 2021 RCEM curriculum. Useful as a short-format question top-up when you’ve already worked through RCEMLearning; useful as a knowledge-check before a sitting. Less useful as your main resource — 200 questions will not cover a 2021 curriculum on their own. Not a standalone resource: at least one r/doctorsUK candidate reports using it alongside RCEMLearning and a Bromley course and still failing. Buy it as a supplement, not a substitute.

EM Final Exams earns no commission on the products reviewed below. The only product we sell is EMF Premium, disclosed wherever it appears in the comparison.

Prices below are in GBP. As a rough guide for 2026: £1 ≈ $1.27 USD ≈ ₹107 INR — check current FX at xe.com before purchasing.

Quick decision matrix

What is the Tom Jaconelli FRCEM book, exactly?

The book in question is SBAs for the FRCEM, written by Dr Tom Jaconelli (MB BS, DLM, FRCEM, FHEA), a Consultant in Emergency Medicine at York Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust and Honorary Senior Lecturer at Hull York Medical School. There is no separate “Top Tips for FRCEM” or “Get Through FRCEM” title by the same author — if someone has recommended “the Jaconelli book”, this is the one.

• Title: SBAs for the FRCEM
• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Published: 15 September 2022
• ISBN-13: 978-1009001670
• Format: Paperback, 180 pages (also available as Kindle eBook)
• Questions: 200 Single Best Answer items with fully referenced explanations
• UK RRP: £31.00 (Waterstones, May 2026)
• Curriculum: Mapped to the RCEM 2021 curriculum, the first dedicated SBA book for the new fellowship paper

Topic coverage spans cardiology, environmental emergencies, mental health, toxicology, trauma, resuscitation and quality improvement. Answers are referenced to current guidelines and research so you can drill deeper on weak areas rather than memorise an answer in isolation. See also our guide to Tintinalli vs Rosen for FRCEM SBA.

What do FRCEM candidates actually say about it?

Across Amazon UK (38 ratings, 4.4/5 as of May 2026) the picture is broadly positive, but the praise is consistent in its shape: it’s an exam-prep tool, not a textbook.

• 67% 5-star, 19% 4-star, 11% 3-star, 0% 2-star, 3% 1-star.
• Jamie Squire (verified purchase, 4 Feb 2026): “Great book. Essential for those taking exams but also just great for home CPD. Very informative, well written and great for knowledge check.”
• James Henry Realf Harrison (verified, 2 Feb 2026, 4-star): “Used in my successful FRCEM attempt. May be more difficult than some of the material on the exam, but otherwise worth the purchase. Be aware may not align with the exam if the curriculum changes.”
• DrA (verified, 16 Jun 2023): “A worthwhile purchase for the FRCEM SBA.”
• Claire (verified, 7 Nov 2022): “Invaluable resource for FRCEM SBA examination preparation.”

The contrarian voice worth listening to is on Reddit. A November 2025 post on r/doctorsUK (“FRCEM SBA”) from a candidate who had failed the paper wrote that they had “revised whole rcemlearning, joined Bromley review course, and used Tom Jaconelli book to no avail.” That is one data point, not a verdict — but it is a useful corrective to the publisher framing of “essential text”. Doing every Jaconelli question correctly does not, by itself, get you through the SBA paper. See also our guide to our King-Patterson Revision Notes review.

Is the book aligned to the current FRCEM SBA paper?

Mostly yes, with caveats. The book was written specifically for the 2021 RCEM curriculum and the new SBA paper format that replaced the old SAQ. The two papers of 90 SBAs each (180 total) and the topic blueprint the book maps to are the same one you’ll be sitting in 2026.

Two caveats from the user reviews:

• Difficulty calibration. Multiple reviewers note the questions sit slightly above the difficulty of the live paper. That is arguably useful for revision (stretch beats coast), but candidates expecting a faithful mock should adjust expectations.
• Guideline drift. The book references guidelines current to early 2022. NICE, RCEM Best Practice and toxicology guidance move — check answers against RCEMLearning and the latest RCEM resources if anything looks off, particularly in toxicology, sepsis, ACS pathways and paediatric resuscitation.

How does Jaconelli compare to other FRCEM SBA resources?

Nothing in this category is a one-stop shop. Here is roughly how the main UK FRCEM SBA resources stack up against each other — based on RCEMLearning’s own published guidance and recurring Reddit recommendations.

The pattern across successful candidates — including Luka Randic medal-winner accounts published on RCEMLearning — is: RCEMLearning as the spine, plus 1–2 question banks, plus one book for offline reinforcement. Jaconelli fits cleanly into that third slot. See also our guide to the best FRCEM SBA question bank for 2026.

Who should buy SBAs for the FRCEM?

• FRCEM SBA candidates 6–12 weeks out who want a short, focused question set to identify gaps before the final push.
• IMG candidates who want a structured printed resource to reinforce RCEMLearning modules.
• Consultants and senior trainees using it for home CPD or to refresh SBA-style reasoning — one of the most positive recent reviews explicitly frames it that way.
• Anyone whose hospital library doesn’t have it — at £31 it’s a reasonable personal copy and the explanations are referenced for further reading.

Who probably shouldn’t rely on this book?

• Anyone treating it as their main resource. 200 questions cannot cover the breadth of a 2021 RCEM curriculum. The Reddit poster who failed despite Jaconelli, RCEMLearning and Bromley is a useful warning — even a stacked toolkit does not pass the paper unless your underlying clinical knowledge and SBA reasoning are solid.
• Candidates whose weakness is exam technique, not knowledge. The book teaches content via SBAs; it does not coach you on how to deconstruct an SBA stem, eliminate distractors or manage time across 90 questions in 120 minutes. For that, RCEMLearning’s exam-prep blog and recorded medal-winner accounts are more useful.
• Candidates very close to a 2026 sitting who already own a larger online question bank. Diminishing returns on a 200-question print book if you already have 1,000+ online questions to work through.

Pros and cons at a glance

If Jaconelli falls short, what should you add?

The honest answer from the RCEMLearning blogs and successful candidate write-ups is that volume of question practice is what closes the SBA gap, alongside curriculum-aligned reading. Sensible add-ons:

• RCEMLearning SBAs, SAQs, sessions and clinical cases. Free, curriculum-mapped, written with examiner input. This is the spine; everything else is a supplement.
• A second question bank for volume. StudyFRCEM, Bromley or FRCEMTutor depending on budget; treat FRCEMQbank with the caveats noted by RCEMLearning’s own blog.
• Podcasts and blogs for retention while commuting: St Emlyn’s, The Resus Room, EM Cases (Canadian, but high-quality), First10EM, LITFL.
• Targeted topic resources: LITFL ECG library, APLS/ATLS material, NICE CKS, and the RCEM Best Practice and Top 10 Drugs guidelines.
• An exam-technique pass: read the FRCEM Information and Regulations pack, do at least one timed mock under exam conditions, and read the medal-winner write-ups on RCEMLearning for what “good” looks like on the day.

How should you actually use the Jaconelli book?

A pragmatic protocol from how successful candidates describe using printed SBA books:

1. Don’t open it first. Get 60–80% of the way through your RCEMLearning sessions and at least one online bank before you touch it.
2. Use it as a gap-finder. Do 20–30 questions in a sitting, mark them honestly, and use the explanations as a jump-off into RCEMLearning or NICE for any topic you got wrong or guessed.
3. Cross-reference toxicology, sepsis, ACS and paediatric resus answers against current RCEM Best Practice. Don’t memorise a 2022-era answer that has since changed.
4. Do the last 50–60 questions under timed conditions as a mini-mock in the final 1–2 weeks.
5. Re-review every question you got wrong the day before the exam. Wrong-answer review beats fresh question volume in the final 24 hours.

Is it worth £31 in 2026?

For most FRCEM SBA candidates, yes — with realistic expectations. You are paying for 200 referenced, curriculum-mapped SBA practice questions from a credible UK consultant, published by Cambridge. The 4.4/5 rating from 38 verified-purchase reviewers is consistent with a useful supplement, not a transformative resource. The minority view that it didn’t help is real and worth respecting: if you can only afford one resource, spend on RCEMLearning premium content and an online bank before this. If you can afford both, it earns its place.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a separate Tom Jaconelli FRCEM book called “Top Tips for FRCEM” or “Get Through FRCEM”?

No. The only Tom Jaconelli FRCEM title in the Cambridge catalogue is SBAs for the FRCEM (ISBN 978-1009001670, Sept 2022). If a colleague has recommended “the Jaconelli book”, this is it.

How many questions are in the book?

200 Single Best Answer questions with full answer explanations and references.

Does the book cover the OSCE as well?

No. It is SBA-only. For the OSCE, the most-cited resources on RCEMLearning and Reddit are the St Emlyn’s OSCE guide and OUP’s OSCE Revision for the Final FRCEM (Rachel et al.) — the latter is the most common “frequently bought together” pairing on Amazon.

Is the Kindle edition any good?

The Kindle eBook is available (ASIN B0B7JV381H) and contains the same content as the paperback. It’s fine for travel revision; the paperback is easier to annotate.

Are the difficulty levels representative of the real exam?

Verified-purchase reviewers consistently describe the questions as slightly harder than the live paper. That makes the book useful for stretch revision but a poor calibration tool if you want to predict your actual SBA score.

Are the references in the book up to date for a 2026 sitting?

References are current to early 2022. The core clinical content (anatomy, drug doses, classic decision rules) hasn’t moved; guideline-driven topics (toxicology, sepsis, ACS pathways, paediatric resus, mental health) should be cross-checked against the latest RCEM Best Practice and NICE/NICE CKS guidance before exam day.

Will it cover paediatrics, ultrasound, mental health and quality improvement?

Yes — the question set is mapped to the curriculum and explicitly covers cardiology, environmental emergencies, mental health, toxicology, trauma, resuscitation and quality improvement. Paediatrics, research/statistics and POCUS appear within the broader question set but are not given their own dedicated chapters.

Should I buy this book or a question bank if I can only afford one?

Most successful candidates and RCEMLearning’s own guidance point to the online RCEMLearning content plus one question bank as the higher-yield spend. Buy this book second.

Is it useful for MRCEM Primary or MRCEM Intermediate SBA?

No — it is written for the FRCEM (final) SBA paper under the 2021 RCEM curriculum. For MRCEM Primary, use basic-science focused resources; for MRCEM Intermediate SBA, RCEMLearning and a dedicated MRCEM bank are higher-yield.

How is the Reddit “used to no avail” comment best interpreted?

Honestly: as a reminder that no single resource — book, course or bank — passes the SBA on its own. The candidate in question had also worked through RCEMLearning and a Bromley course. Failure on the FRCEM SBA usually reflects gaps in clinical reasoning or exam technique, not the bibliography on the desk.

Is there a second edition planned?

None announced by Cambridge University Press as of May 2026. The 2022 first edition remains the current edition.

Is the book available second-hand?

Yes — verified-purchase eBay UK listings have sold copies around £26–£28 in 2025–2026. Given the modest curriculum drift, a second-hand 2022 copy is functionally identical to a new one for SBA practice purposes, as long as you cross-check guideline-sensitive topics.

Next step

If you’re building an FRCEM SBA revision plan and want a structured, exam-focused walk-through — including resource shortlists, weak-area drills and SBA technique — start at emfinalexams.com. The site is built specifically for UK FRCEM and MRCEM candidates, and the SBA modules slot directly alongside resources like Jaconelli.

Facts last verified 30 May 2026. Book details from Cambridge University Press, Waterstones and Amazon UK product listings; verified-purchase quotes from Amazon UK reviews; community comment from r/doctorsUK thread “FRCEM SBA” (post id 1p19ebb); resource comparison cross-referenced with RCEMLearning’s published exam guidance.

Ready to build your plan? EMF Premium gives you all 40,000 questions and 20 mocks for £59 — one payment, six months' access.