Home/Critical Appraisal
Critical Appraisal

Normal & Skewed Distributions

EM FINAL EXAMS Critical Appraisal · Statistics Normal & Skewed Distributions The shape of the data decides the right summary and the right test. Definition A normal (Gaussian) distribution is symmetric and bell-shaped: mean = median = mode, with about 68 / 95 / 99.7% of values within 1 / 2 / 3 standard deviations. […]

EM FINAL EXAMS Critical Appraisal · Statistics

Normal & Skewed Distributions

The shape of the data decides the right summary and the right test.

Definition

A normal (Gaussian) distribution is symmetric and bell-shaped: mean = median = mode, with about 68 / 95 / 99.7% of values within 1 / 2 / 3 standard deviations. Skewed data are asymmetric: a right (positive) skew has a long right tail, dragging the mean above the median.

The picture
Normal mean = median = mode Right skew median mean → Normal: ~68 / 95 / 99.7% of values lie within 1 / 2 / 3 SD of the mean Skew → the tail drags the mean

Symmetric → mean = median; right-skewed → the long tail drags the mean past the median.

What it shows

Two distributions side by side. In the symmetric normal curve the mean, median and mode sit together. In the right-skewed curve the bulk of values cluster low with a long tail of high values; the median stays at the peak while the mean is pulled out towards the tail.

How to read it

The shape tells you the right summary. Symmetric → report mean ± SD and use parametric tests. Asymmetric/skewed → report median + IQR and use non-parametric tests. The further the mean drifts from the median, the more skewed the data and the more misleading a mean becomes.

Why it matters

Most ED time variables — length of stay, waiting times, door-to-needle — are right-skewed by a few very long stays. Quoting a mean length of stay overstates the typical patient’s experience, and parametric tests on skewed data can mislead. Checking the distribution first is a basic appraisal discipline.

Key
  • Normal: mean = median = mode, 68/95/99.7%
  • Right skew: mean > median
  • Skewed → median + IQR, non-parametric
Pitfall
Pitfall Reporting mean ± SD, or using parametric tests, on skewed data — the mean is dragged by the tail and misrepresents the typical value. Always check the shape (or assume skew for cost, time and count data) first.
emfinalexams.com · FRCEM / MRCEM revision
EM trial in the wild

Everyday ED examplelength of stay and waiting times are textbook right-skewed: most patients leave quickly, but a long tail of admitted or “boarding” patients stretches the upper end. The honest summary is the median (IQR); a “mean LOS” is inflated by those long-stay outliers and flatters the department. If a paper reports a mean ± SD for length of stay, suspect the distribution was never checked — and treat any parametric comparison with caution.

Examiner traps
  • Using the mean on skewed data — the tail inflates it away from the typical value.
  • Assuming normality without checking (a histogram, or mean vs median).
  • Forgetting that a log or other transformation can normalise skewed data so parametric tests become valid.
Quick check

ED length of stay is right-skewed — report the mean or the median?
Answer: The median (with IQR). The mean is inflated by a few long-stay outliers, so it overstates the typical patient’s length of stay.

Related cards

Ready to build your plan? EMF Premium gives you all 40,000+ questions, 20 mocks and 1,215 OSCE stations from £29/month — or a one-off 3- or 6-month pass.

Share
0
    0
    Your Cart
    Your cart is emptyReturn to Shop